*roundtrip ticket
Ain't no party like a Detroit party
From Mitch Albom
Now it's Detroit. Nice. I know it's just a sentence, but a crown is just a crown, too. It's still the difference between looking at a king and being one.
So the guests of honor have been announced for a Motown party that has been scheduled for years. It will be original. It will be unpredictable. It will be the franchise that once gave us Terry Bradshaw, Lynn Swann, Franco Harris against the franchise that once gave us, uh, Jim Zorn.
And in a nice twist of geographic fate, the most celebrated player likely will be a beefy running back who went to Mackenzie High School and spent part of his televised news conference answering questions about our hometown -- and his.
"What's great about Detroit?" he said. "It's a great city. It's a great city, and you all will see when you get there in two weeks."
Couldn't have said it better ourselves.
If you want to know more
about how politics is affecting the Polish economy, check out this report by Radio Polonia.
When cabbage met chow mein
Poland’s most prominent populist is in China this week despite the current political crisis here at homePolish politics is experiencing an unprecedented period of crisis. The current minority govenrnment led by Law and Justice (PiS) is grasping for any political straws that will bring them at least a temporary coalition before a critical budget vote, which, if it fails or is delayed, could trigger new elections. Yet another set of negotiations with the party that was considered to be its natural coalition partner before last autumn’s elections, Civic Platform, broke down (again) last week, leaving PiS little choice but to renew coalition negotiations this week with the populist farmer’s party Self-defense (SO). However, SO’s leader, the wily former pugilist Andrzej Lepper, isn't interested. He flew to China Sunday at the invitation of the youth communist party there, and was received in Beijing yesterday by Wang Zhaoguo, vice chairman of the Standing Committee of China’s National People’s Congress. Lepper's goal, according to Gazeta Wyborcza (Polish link) is ostensibly "getting to know the mechanisms of the Chinese economy." Apparently, Lepper wants Poland follow China’s example, since "through its own finances, through its own national loan policy, [China] achieved development of industry and agriculture." Interestingly, when Self-defense invited the youth organization to Poland last year, the group’s leader said that Lepper’s program was "similar to our communist one." While Lepper’s policies are undoubtedly of a commie hue, it’s surely the Chinese government’s tight control over the value of the yuan which Lepper finds most intriguing. He is perhaps most famous for his calls for Poland’s top central banker, Leszek Balcerowicz, to be removed from his position, and for matters of monetary policy to be put in the hands of the state. Of course, the Economist-dubbed potato-thrower has no influence over monetary policy now. So why this sudden trip to the Orient at the behest of the Central Committee of the Communist Youth League of China, when the right-wing government at home is gaining in popularity and itching for new elections? Lepper knows that as long as PiS and PO are at each other’s throats, he is the kingmaker in this country. After the failure of a coalition with PO, every other conceivable coalition government with PiS at the helm must include SO. While PiS may do well in an election after a successfully-passed budget (since October PiS has gained a 10-point lead in the polls over PO), failure to pass the budget would confirm the incompetence of the PiS government, who in three months in office have still not formed a coalition, and whose first choices for Treasury Minister and Finance Minister have both resigned in humiliation.That leaves Lepper in a tremendous position of power. In order to go into early elections (which now seem a foregone conclusion) with a strong record behind them, PiS will need the support of Lepper’s party on the budget. Self-defense, on the other hand, has very little reason to support PiS’ budget, which would put PiS in a position to gain an outright majority (hence neutralizing SO) in the early elections. After last week’s farse in which PiS leaders in the Sejm attempted to delay work on the budget for weeks, it’s clear that PiS likes the poll numbers it’s seeing, and wants early elections as soon as possible. However, PiS knows those numbers won’t hold if it can’t even pass a budget for this year, leaving only three choices for PiS: 1) Honor PO’s demands, and form a coalition with them (now highly unlikely); 2) Honor Lepper’s demands (whatever they are), and form a coalition with SO; or 3) Call early elections with no budget, and blame the failure on PO and SO. Since both parties know that only PiS would benefit from early elections, 1 and 2 look increasingly unlikely, unless some major concessions are given to Lepper – which would be extremely bad news for Poland. The third situation is most probable, which is even worse, since despite all of their foul-ups and backtracking, PiS still seems to have a stranglehold on a majority of the Polish public's trust. So Lepper might as well go ahead and spend a week in China, observing their "economic mechanisms" - He's got Poland's whole political future waiting on his return, and if PiS makes a bad bet on early elections, he just may find an opportunity in the future to put what he learns this week to use.
Sunday Vista Blogging XII
So is this kissing ass or showing spine?
Polish press reports that the current government has promised the US support in any future attack on Iran
Recently, discussions on WS and elsewhere have centered around whether Polish military support of the US in Iraq has more to do with self-interest of the enlightened or not-so enlightened sort. Some argue that Poland's presence in Iraq is driven by a will to "help the Iraqi people" - despite the fact that survey after survey shows that Poles want nothing to do with Iraq.
However, today Rzeczpospolita (Polish link) reports that Poland is chomping at the bit to get involved in another of the US' military campaigns, this time of a much less altruistic nature.
The WBJ sums up the Rz article:
Wayne Madsen, a former US military intelligence officer who is currently an independent analyst, stated that Poland has fully backed the administration of George W. Bush and the potential decision it might make to attack Iran. Madsen backed this announcement on anonymous sources from Polish intelligence, and went on to say that during recent visits of Defense Minister Radosław Sikorski, as well as Foreign Minister Stefan Meller, both ensured their counterparts in the USA, Donald Rumsfeld and Condoleezza Rice respectively, that Poland will support a possible attack. According to Rzeczpospolita, the Foreign Ministry denies these allegations, and states that the issue of Iran during the past visits was not even touched upon during the talks. It's widely agreed that if the US indeed were to attack Iran, the campaign would not be an Iraq-style governmental overthrow, but rather a systematic bombing of believed nuclear weapons-making sites, so "helping the Iranian people" is excluded. A bombing campaign would inevitably produce "collateral damage" (heavy loss of innocent Iranian life) for which the US and any of its partners would be roundly criticized. There is no reason to believe that Poles would be any more supportive of an Iranian military adventure than the current Iraqi one, and there is some question as to how much military support Poland could actually give the US in such a situation.
So, if as reported, these promises were indeed made, what in the world could be the Polish government's motivation for making such pacts?
This is about staying on the good side of the guy with the biggest wallet and the biggest guns. Kaczynskis and Co realize that the US is a good partner for a small country which often angers its allies and neighbors to have on its side.
Kissing ass? More like irrigating.
Let freedom ring
Rhode Island has become the 11th state to legalize medical marijuana.
The House overrode a veto by Gov. Don Carcieri, 59-13, allowing people with illnesses such as cancer and AIDS to grow up to 12 marijuana plants or buy 2.5 ounces of marijuana to relieve their symptoms. Those who do are required to register with the state and get an identification card.
|
Ain't no party like a Detroit party
Actually, what IS great about Detroit? One thing (and don't say the Redwings!)?
I think he will probably say redwings.
These all go for the Detroit metro area, which is referred to by everyone who lives there as "Detroit".
What is great about Detroit?
-Detroit's miles of freeway on summer weekends full of classic cars.
-Great music and a great music history. From the Temptations to the White Stripes, from Bob Seger to the Supremes, from Alice Cooper to Stevie Wonder - I could name many, many more. All had their beginnings in Detroit. As a result, we also have some of the best musical traditions - and radio stations! - in the country.
-Some great museums. The Detroit Institute of Art (in the city of Detroit) is perhaps one of the most underappreciated museums in the world. It has a fantastic collection of Egyptian mummies, as well as an extensive collection of impressionists, including some of Monet's most famous. Some of Van Gogh's best are there too.
The Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn is another gem. The very car Kennedy was killed in is there, as well as several exhibits showing the evolution of everything from the steam engine to the modern vacuum cleaner.
-Lakes, lakes, and more lakes. What watersport do you want to engage in today?
-It's reputation as the place where Canada and the US meet. Detroit is a modern-day border town, but is the polar opposite of El Paso or San Diego. Instead of crazed vigilantes sitting in lawnchairs with their rifles aimed at the foreigners coming over the Ambassador Bridge, traffic moves freely across the borders; it's nothing unusual for a someone on either side to cross 2 or three times in one day. Every Detroiter usually has several good Canadian friends, just by default, since so many are around. Of course, travelling to Windsor for your 19th birthday is a great tradition too. This geography also adds to Detroit's history. During prohibition, Detroit was the top spot for rum-running from country to country. Michigan was the first state to vote for the prohibition amendment, as well as the first to vote for its repeal.
-Great people. Of course, many cities can say that, but few have been through the prolonged decay that Detroit has. Detroit still hasn't recovered from the seizures that gripped it in the middle of the last century - the city itself is quite empty and in many places, bleak. Detroiters are perennially optimistic though, and proud of where they come from. New businesses are moving in, the theater district and Greektown are a blast. With two new stadiums and a boost from the gaming industry, the economy there is picking up. As I touched on when I mentioned music, Detroit has a very rich history. That also includes being the country's industrial heartland and providing automobiles for the country, and finally, the world. It's not a tradition we take lightly.
-Oh yeah, and the Red Wings rock.
Probably, you're not very impressed by this list. After all, Chicago and Warsaw also have their own benefits, and it could be argued, ones that make those cities "greater". So what is it then that really makes Detroit "great"? Well, I think that's the whole point. Detroit is about a certain atmosphere - a certain pride. As just about everyone knows, there's little concrete to brag about, but we love our town just the same.
It's great, just great, is just about all a Detroiter can say, because how do you provide tangible proof for the intangible? What evidence do you present? I've made an effort here, but in reality, Bettis said it best. The "greatness" of Detroit is something that has to be experienced first-hand. You realize it more than anything else when you meet the PEOPLE. - They are truly what makes Detroit great.
But it's something you have to experience for yourself. Detroit may be the butt of the rest of the counry's jokes (another reason Detroiters are so [defiantly] proud), but those who have visited tend to leave with a smile on their faces.
Let me just mention frm personal expieriance that if you go Windsor three times in one day for no good reason, you're asking for a full-body cavity search.
You forgot to mention the remaining small Polish enclave in the city!
I've been across the border several times (including 3 times in one day) and have never been searched. Just lucky I guess.
Technically, Hamtramck is its own city. They had a funny incident last year with some raucus-causin' Muslims. Seems some of the traditional Polish Catholics there don't mind churchbells to ring your hangover awake at 6 am on a Sunday morning, but a 5 am call to prayer for Muslims is just too much. Mercifully, The majority of Hamtramck residents possess common sense.
By the way, here's how Little Green Footballs reported the story. "an exemption from noise ordinances "? Sheesh.
Though, to be fair, the report is a republished article from the Detroit News, which is considered a "conservative" paper. With phrases like: "waves of outrage from Christian groups" and "special rights" - I can see where they get that moniker.
I never knew that Hamtramck was a city inside a city, pretty cool. I'm curious how Detroit will be portrayed leading up to the Super Bowl.
Yes, Hamtramck is our Lesotho.
I'm curious to see how Detroit is portrayed after the Super Bowl. Though outside Ford Field on an early February night is no place for hooligans to start some shit. Too cold.
Windsor is where the bloody Queen lives, you colonials!!!
Superbowl.....whats that?
In the immortal words of Meatloaf, Two out of three ain't bad.
What do you expect when you get in a shootout in Texas.
Let me see, who is Number one in the Western Conference now.....why, that would be the Dallas Stars. I guess the cream does rise to the top.
A hockey all star game - in Texas?
Will anybody come? The biggest hometown star they could find to promote the thing is also a former Wing!
As far as the shootout goes, it sounded really exciting - and on national TV too, which is good for the sport.
But I'm apoplectic with fury at the result. You guys sure are happy that you finally managed to beat us, though. Poor Turco. And anyways, shootouts are for cowboys, not hockey. What is this, soccer? I get enough shootouts over here.
And what's that about being first in the conference? Check again. By my count we've still got a point on ya. But that could all change tonight. Both teams are playing.
All I got to say is: Playoffs baby. Playoffs.
Yeah, I forgot, they had to give y'all a point for losing. ;-)
I sure wish we were in a division with Columbus, Chicago, and St. Loses. We would already have the President's cup clinched.
Rather than perennial powerhouses like LA, Anaheim, San Jose and Phoenix? Sure, LA is decent this year, but that's an anomaly - as it is that St. Lou is having a bad year.
The only thing that makes that division tough is the slush all you southwestern teams have to skate on in that heat. At least in Columbus they have ice.
What else makes Detroit great? It was the birthplace of techno and for a great many years held some of the best vibe underground rave parties in North America.
I found this post by Googling, "Ain't no party like a Detroit party" (because a Detroit party don't stop). Where I first heard that saying? In some dirty warehouse at 6 in the morning the night of April 1st, 2000.
Excellent point Likwidshoe. Techno is another integral part of the city's vibrant music history - and fewer people know about it than should. Detroit holds one of the world's best Techno festivals each year as well.
If you want to know more
It is a good report. They seem to have picked up a new, fresh faced analyst, alongside people like Stanislaw Gamulka, one of the advisers to the economic "Shock Therapy' of the earky 1990's.
That "fresh-faced" analyst just sounds like a Republican to me.
blech.
A great essay on the good points of Detroit. I have lived in many American cities and visited many other cities all over the world. I have enjoyed many of them. One of the differentiating characteristics of Detroit is that is not like other cities. It is more of a "big town" than a true city and that is due largely to the high degree of home ownership within the city and less of the apartment downtown living of others. That has its disadvantages for the downtown, but it does create a different attitude of the people than you find elsewhere.
When cabbage met chow mein
Nice post.
But if he is in such a position of power, then don't you think he would better be back in Warsaw? I think that Samoobrona can see an election coming. They have 3% in the polls. They cannot get PiS to give them a cabinet post. Things are not really in their control. PiS is calling the shots.
Poland has 4 percent growth, China has 10 and is going up like a Chinese rocket! So maybe it wouldn't be such a bad idea to have Chairman Lepper as President!
And what is so wrong with taking monetary policy back into government control? At least people voted for PiS. They are accountable - Central bankers are not.
Any chance we can talk the Chinese into keeping him there?
Nice try beatroot ;-)
Back in Warsaw? What for? So he can appear on some talkshows where he gets torn to pieces by a politician from another party, or maybe so he can make another farsical speech on the floor of the Sejm and be presented as a clown in the media again?
No, Lepper get's wilier and more astute all the time. Whoever this official is who he met with in Beijing, he sounds important - which immediately raises his clout, and gives him a great story in the media, while in the same cycle PiS is flailing about trying to patch a coalition together. While the Duck brothers are at home slinging mud, Lepper is meeting with high-powered Chinese officials and discussing matters of economics. This is some great political maneuvering just before an election.
Poland has 4 percent growth, China has 10 and is going up like a Chinese rocket! So maybe it wouldn't be such a bad idea to have Chairman Lepper as President!
Boy, I sure hope that's playing devil's advocate. The danger of a Chinese rocket is that it has the potential to either explode in mid-air or hurtle crashing to the ground. With crazy, politically driven pilots manning the monetary-policy controls, that's even more likely to happen. Consistently stable growing economies are cooked long and slowly like good Polish bigos. Four percent is a lovely rate to be growing at.
And what is so wrong with taking monetary policy back into government control? At least people voted for PiS. They are accountable - Central bankers are not.
The problem is that they are accountable to constituents who may not share the goal of keeping inflation low. Central bankers must be free of political pressures if they are to make the best decisions for monetary policy. If Alan Greenspan had been required to run for his office, he may have been tempted to lower interest rates more quickly or raise them more slowly, which could have had disastrous effects.
Andrew:
Thanks. I'm working on posting more often and consistently. Sorry for the recent silence.
Michael: Not a chance in hell.
Gustav.
The Chinese are following a south asian model of development - and it's a better model than the one Poland is stuck with, maybe.
The communists are maintaining a strong state but a relativly free market. That's the same as the Japanese,the South Koreans, Hong Kong and Singapore have always done it.
it's a good model! It works. The African model that all these western NGOs want, does not.
And the central european model - in Poland's case - is inferior. People have more 'freedom' here, but they don't really use it, and many don't have the benifits of the free market.
So maybe the Asian model is the best?
Beatroot,
Where were you the last ten years? Did you miss that whole decade of recession Japan experienced? So much for the "Asian model", only now that Koizumi is untangling the state from business (eg, privatizing the post office) is the economy beginning to take off.
The same with China. It's not growing strongly because there is heavy state interventionk, it's growing strongly despite it. Only when China's leaders decided to OPEN it's market did China's economy started taking off. I guarantee you that whenever you open an economy of a-billion-and-change consumers and laborers, that economy will experience rapid short-term growth. If China wants its economy to remain strong though, they're going to have to weaken the state's hand in the economy.
Hong Kong and Singapore also benefit from an excellent geographical location for trade, and have super-low taxes. Hong Kong link | Singapore link
The Asian model not only depends on the strong state, but also on mega-corporations (as in Japan and S. Korea). With the health of the economy depending on so few entities (ie a few big corporations and the state) stagnation comes very easily.
Every good investor knows that if you want stable growth in your portfolio, it's best to diversify. Hundreds of thousands of small and medium-sized businesses account for something like 90% Poland's economic productivity. This model - which is present in Poland, Europe, and the US - is the superior one, as the Chinese are sure to learn if they halt their gradual reform/liberalization of the market.
The African model is not working precisely because of government meddling - from both inside and out. Proper economic development there will have to be preceded by a change in political culture at home, and the real liberalization of trade abroad (no more of this, "you free up your markets to us, but we still get to charge tarrifs on your products and dictate what you produce" bs).
People have more 'freedom' here, but they don't really use it, and many don't have the benifits of the free market.
Did I understand you right that you would rather live in a country with 10% growth and China-style oppression than a liberal democracy that is growing more slowly? - And because most people don't "use" their freedoms? (whatever that means)
As Mom used to say, better to have something and not need it than need it and not have it. I'm not willing to give up my unused freedoms for a flash-in-the-pan 10% growth. Those freedoms just might come in handy one day...
Sunday Vista Blogging XII
So is this kissing ass or showing spine?
The US is geographically far enough from Poland that it is perceived as non-threatening. And, the US has yet to really burn Poland. Lots of little indignities, but nothing hugely major.
The Polish government is also hoping/convinced that having the US as a strong ally will act as a deterrent against Russia if/when Russia returns to an agressively expansionist military policy. Failing to act as a deterrent, the Polish government hopes for military assistance in said scenario.
I myself am fairly sure that the US would not offer more than verbal support in such an eventuality.
That said, it's devotion to the US has cost Poland in the EU and will cost it more especially in terms of gaining a reputation as being a poor ally/member. Hint: you can't play on two teams at the same time
Nail on the head, Michael.
Poland's best hope was to become the type of bridge between Europe and the US that Britain is. I still hold out hope that it could be, but it's done such a good job of turning EU allies away that I don't think it has any of their trust. The bridge has been burned on the EU side, and it will take a while before it's rebuilt.
That said, it's devotion to the US has cost Poland in the EU and will cost it more especially in terms of gaining a reputation as being a poor ally/member. Hint: you can't play on two teams at the same time.
Perhaps having recently lived under the rule of a real dictator gives the Poles, and the rest of Eastern Europe, much better perspective than the cowards who benefited from the Marshall Plan and American military presence throughout the cold war.
Maybe thats why they don't share the western weenie's jealousy and resentment that fuels their irrational Americaphobia.
Maybe Poland and eastern Europe has not been free long enough to share the west's arrogant attitude towards condemning the Americans for having the balls to keep Europe out of the range of Iranian nuclear missiles. Maybe the new Polish government has enough class and self-respect not to just sit back and let their new ally do all the heavy lifting that ultimately will benefit Poland's security more than Americas.
Y'all are always crying that Poland's relationship with America has not brought Poland instant prosperity, but exactly where would Poland be today if America (Reagan) had not forced the Soviet Union to spend itself into collapse?
I myself am fairly sure that the US would not offer more than verbal support in such an eventuality.
What are you expecting from Poland's EU allies in the event of a resurgence in Russian aggression? About the same as last time?
It appears to me that America shows more respect for Poland than Poland's EU buddies do, seems like a no brainer why they would support America in it's role as the world's policemen......its the right thing to do.
ttsxjmy ncyie
Redneck, can I ask what your experience with Poland and/or Polish people has been? I've lived here for over 10 years and can't recognize anything relevant to Poland in what you write.
First, you assume that Polish people have similar ideas toward government (and specifically the US government) and Poland's past that Americans have. I've never come across any evidence to make me think that.
Are Polish people glad the communist era is over? Overwhelmingly yes. Do they regard it as a time of repression? Not especially (among most). It was economically more unpopular than politically (which is why former party members won so many elections). Kaczynski won the presidential election _despite_ his hard line anti (post)-communist leanings, not because of them.
On the whole Polish people respect Americans as people who know what they want (money) and go after it but we're also seen as naive, politically immature and prone to panic (and simplisitically religious rather than spiritual). US governments are generally evaluated on their pro-Polish (in word and deed) stance. The first Bush was very popular as was Clinton (after a slow, uncertain start). Most people have not warmed to Bush II who's most often seen as a lightweight who's done nothing for Poland after Poland has risked a lot to support the US.
In the Polish media, I've yet to hear Polish participation described in terms of bringing democracy to Iraq. They don't even pretend it's about anything but supporting the US.
Poland voted to join the EU and there's _no_ will to leave now. As things stand now, Poland doesn't really have _any_ allies in the EU. Spain under Aznar was an ally but his party's defeat ended that. Britain was an ally but Poland (and other countries) publicly humiliating Blair over the budget ended that. Poland needs to create some allies within the EU and just doing anything Washington wants isn't going to get that done.
"Michael, you are either a complete fool or you and your friends are too young to remember what it was really like."
Why thank you kindly. My remarks are based on many dozens (if not hundreds) of conversations with Polish people over many years from all walks of life who lived large chunks of their lives in the Polish Peoples Republic.
What people mention about the communist period is primarily material inconvenience (lines and rations). There really is not that much talk about politics one way or the other (even from those who suffered politically a modern cliche is the most strident anti communists now didn't do much then). There were exceptionally bad periods but those were mostly the exception, not the rule. Poland wasn't East Germany or Romania. Poland at its worst, as in martial law, was still probably freer than peoples Romania at its most lax. IME Polish people in the great majority are absolutely oblivious to politics (determinedly so) and grimly indifferent about form of government provided they can provide for their families and the government doesn't interfere too much in their personal business.
All in all, Polish memories of the PRL (people's republic) in Poland (as opposed to those who emigrated then) are conflicting and complex. They certainly don't correspond with what conservative Americans think/wish that Polish people think. You might not like it (I'm not always happy about how little Polish people are interested in who makes up the government) but that does seem to be the way of it.
Pierrem: I agree with you that Polish governments feel they have no choice but to go with the US on defense matters.
But Pierrem - we generally have a rule on these blogs that discourages personal remarks...so please, let's battle about ideas, and not trade insults.
But Mike is right, Poles do have complicated memories about the past here. It all depends on how well they are doing in the new capitalist Poland. If they are the new middle class then communist days have no attraction at all. But if you are an unemployed miner, or a pensioner, or just some of the older Poles who think that all this new (capitalist) popular culture is a disgrace, then the old days can seem, through communist red rosy glasses, to be a much safer place than today.
Well Paul Bremer's book criticising the Polish contingent in Iraq as useless will certainly help!
Let freedom ring
|